Does Hon. Martha Karua deserve the presidency? PDF Print E-mail
Written by Capt. Collins Wanderi Munyiri   
Thursday, 07 August 2008

My heroine, the indefatigable Minister for Justice, Constitutional Affairs and National Cohesion, Hon. Martha Wangari Karua wants to be president and Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of the Republic of Kenya.

Is her's a serious bid for the presidency or just another gush of hot air? I am unable to refrain from offering her my 50 cents worth of advice because I am afraid to mourn the loss of a promising political leader.

Waziri, you have an inalienable democratic right to aspire and vie for any public office in Kenya. Having represented the people of Gichugu in parliament for the last 16 years, and held high-profile jobs in the government and political parties, you have the credentials to aspire to the position of Commander-in-Chief. As the current chairperson of NARC-Kenya, you have a head start as primus-inter-pares among the leaders aspiring to inherit President Kibaki's perceived political mantle in the PNU coalition. 

Defying State House in the matter of dissolving PNU's constituent parties has bolstered and reaffirmed your image and characteristic aura of political independence. You should pay little attention to the busy bodies in PNU, and completely ignore President Kibaki in this matter. The president is not a political animal; he is unlikely to play any major role in the 2012 elections. President Kibaki is not, and never has been, a serious political party ideologue or mobiliser. You and his other friends hurriedly cobbled up PNU just to save him from being party-less in September last year. It is his disdain for party politics that led to the collapse of the original NARC, rendered his DP a moribund outfit, and created the House of Babel that is PNU. Not even the president's sudden interest in, and ascension to, the leadership of PNU can salvage the coalition. The president has no vehicle for political mobilisation or grassroots machinery of his own; and hence no political fortune or mantle to bequeath to anybody. If anything, the entire Mt. Kenya region is littered with political orphans of his former parties with no evident heir of note in sight. Politicians hinging their survival on President Kibaki after 2012 are simply suffering a bout of collective amnesia and busy writing their political epitaphs.

However, Waziri, charity, even in politics, begins at home. Avoid attacking the Deputy Premier Hon. Uhuru Muigai Kenyatta and Security Minister, Hon George Muthengi Kinuthia Saitoti. Doing so does not endear you to a lot of people in southern Kikuyu land. If anything, your thinly veiled attacks against the duo are slowly rekindling the old wounds and fault lines (the fabled Chania River divide) between the northern and southern Kikuyu. Take this matter seriously, since you do not have any serious cheer-leaders outside Kirinyaga District and as we speak, NARC-Kenya has lost the support of  most sitting MPs in the larger Nyeri, Laikipia and Nyandarua Districts. Your only saving grace here is that your defiance against the president and the "big-moneyed elitist minority" wheeler-dealers resonates well with the majority of the young people in Mt. Kenya region who are tired of the old order and the current status quo. Get a young, energetic party ideologue to harness the political support of the youth and you will pull the rug under your detractors in Central Kenya.  

Outside Central Kenya, some people view you as a rabble rousing inveterate Kikuyu chauvinist. You need to re-brand and modify this image through your most visible allies Hon. MPs Dr. Mohamed Kuti, Danson Buya Mungatana (my former college mate), Katoo Ole Metito, Asman Kamama Abongotum and Robinson Njeru Githae. Spend much more time creating a grassroots machinery for NARC-Kenya. The party needs serious, credible, and clearly-visible groundsmen. You need to organise and open well managed party branches in every constituency to create alternative centres of power, disorganise and scatter sitting MPs and set a foothold in every corner of Kenya.      

Whereas you have impeccable credentials in the fight for democracy, civil and political liberties, you have not championed the fight for social, economic and judicial reforms in similar fashion. Poor and unrepresented litigants rarely access substantive justice in Kenya while the rich and powerful easily get reprieve from the courts. Judicial officers often refuse to see "real justice" through the miasma of primordial technicalities of procedure which the rich readily exploit. Our criminal justice system now seems to be a haven for criminals who are cleared after committing serious crimes such as murder, rape and robbery with violence. We have not heard your voice on the issue of murder suspects walking scot-free due to procedural technicalities. You must radically reform this system that only seems to perceive "justice" through the lenses of the villains and not the victims. You understand the quid pro quo doctrine well, and four years is a long time; stand for the majority.   

Waziri, use the constitutional reform and the gender equity agenda to your advantage. Nothing would endear you more to Kenyans than the attainment of genuine constitutional and legal reforms under your watch. Women constitute 52% of the productive population in Kenya but have been disfranchised by historical disadvantage. After close to five decades of misrule by the lethargic and corrupt male-dominated regimes that have entrenched poverty and social and gender inequity, it will be not difficult to package and sell the idea of a principled, untainted, compassionate, and trustworthy woman leader to Kenyans.

Trackback(0)
Comments (51)add
 1 2 3 > 
795
...
written by mkosakabila , August 07, 2008

five decades of misrule by the lethargic and corrupt male-dominated regimes that have entrenched poverty and social and gender inequity


That's how bad its been, eh? WOW!
Time to shift gears.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
112
I support Martha but ...
written by pndiangui , August 07, 2008
I support Martha sorely on the basis of her character and change credentials but she needs to change her approach.
She needs to be seen to be abit more motherly and infact she hire an image consultant. To be a bit more presidential while also doning a heart of a genuine change agent who can guner support across the country. It is particularly time to re-ignite bonds with Mukisa Kituyi , Tuju, Kirwa and Prof Kivutha Kibwana.
They need to appeal to a segment of Kenyans that is de-tribalized tired of tribal chiefs deal making.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
795
...
written by mkosakabila , August 07, 2008
pndiangui:
Might something like this help to smooth the edges?
Link here

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
270
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , August 08, 2008
After close to five decades of misrule by the lethargic and corrupt male-dominated regimes that have entrenched poverty and social and gender inequity, it will be not difficult to package and sell the idea of a principled, untainted, compassionate, and trustworthy woman leader to Kenyans.
Thankfully, unlike Ngilu and the Captain, Ms Karua sees herself as a Kenyan chasing after public office, not a woman, not a Gikuyu but just a Kenyan. This is what has endeared many of us to her.

I am not convinced we should give up on the Justice Minister though, she forms a very significant part of the alliance that must be built up to resist the ODM and their foreign masters. I sympathise totally with her anger at being passed up for the position of DPM, to be bested by the ridiculous Uhuru Kenyatta, who would not be angry at that?

Perhaps this is Kalonzo, Kiraitu, Tuju, Nyamweya, Ongeri, Haji, etc's first task, to get these two together. The anti-corruption, reformist credentials of Karua, Mungatana, etc are too important to neglect. Tragic that we live in a country where Uhuru's money can mean so much politically, but it is also true for Kenya that the battle between the forces for reform and the corrupt network needs to be settled outside of the zero sum game of an election, outside of the park where it can be framed as a battle between good tribes and bad ones. Much better to have the spit and fury inside a party boardroom, than in the slums of Nairobi and the fields of the Rift Valley.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
429
Give us a break....
written by jaya wardene , August 08, 2008
If anybody knows the real problems of Kenya today they will tell you that instead of development and growth we are constantly politicking. In 2003 the MOU was dumped into the dustbin like a piece of rotting fish and the original Narc disintegrated with rival factions positioning themselves for 2007....five wasted years and look where that got us.

Dear Captain and others the country's wounds are still not healed. As you rightly say, Martha Karua has been in positions of influence for a pretty long time. Why do you want to use an old piece of cloth to patch your trousers? It is Karua and people like her who have ruined this country. They will never be part of the solution.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
198
short answer...no
written by John Ongeri , August 08, 2008
Whilst I have nothing against the Justice minister I have to say that she has no chance. This article has actually sealed her fate by painting her firmly in a tribal setting. I would even go as far as to say that the writer should have titled his piece: Does Karua deserve to be a leader in the Gikuyu tribe? After all the whole piece is about the political misadventures of the PNU, Kibaki, Uhuru, 'Southern and Northern' Kikuyus and that old story about motor-bikes over the river. None of this, however important to Karua, will make any difference to the majority of Kenyans. Karua or any other leader with ambitions to lead will have to demonstrate clear National credentials.

Having a small handful of also-ran allies from communities other than your own does not make you a National figure capable of ruling a country as diverse as ours.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
cut out the rubbish
written by A Wairimu , August 08, 2008
Let's try and cut out the rubbish. Martha Karua distinguished herself in her time as a Minister, both for pushing reforms, for defending the truth (at and after the election) and allowing her subordinates to perform ( Dorothy Angote and the whole GJLOS effort). She is part of the solution, and that is what makes her present conduct so very disturbing. Kenya will be sorry for any government in which her considerable talents are taken to Bondo, or otherwise denied to this side of the fence. Most importantly, Martha Karua is not a thief. For sure most of the people who hate Martha Karua so passionately have no reason other than her gender. I cannot see why anyone would call her a hardliner.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Guest , August 08, 2008
Excellent comment by "A. Wairimu" - every single word is precise and correct. One could not express it briefer nor more to the point.

Thank you for this.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
795
...
written by mkosakabila , August 08, 2008
Uhuru? He’s as uninspiring as he’s unconvincing. Fuhggedaboud that! For now.
Ndiangui’s repackaging—a gentler countenance on a very capable and accomplished woman—not a bad idea. Not bad at all.
Also not a bad idea to start reaching out to women’s organizations and their women leaders across the political divide, across the country. Including those organizations that have mandated themselves with civic education. Capture their issues and their imagination, have them matter, not just because they can sing and dance. There’s a whole lot more going on there. A lot of work ahead.
Then the youth—most helpful that she seems to have a good group of youthful MPs working closely with her.
My very best to this candidate, whose fate is absolutely not sealed by the one measly article on KI.

Hey Guest: do yu ever get this strange feeling that IDs can be fuzzy, sort of, on KI?


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
0
...
written by Mogoka Shtim , August 08, 2008
"For sure most of the people who hate Martha Karua so passionately have no reason other than her gender"

ahh setting the tone and narrative early are we?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
185
...
written by abdulmote , August 08, 2008
The fact that Martha is a women does not necessarily promise a better leadership qualities in her goodself. Indeed she has nothing to show of her feminine side which suggests she could be that chanpion for our good mothers, sisters, daughters, wives and our grannies. Her only outstanding abilities that I can see so far is in her recent robust defence for President Mwai Kibaki. Such an effort is neither nor there when it comes to being a good rep for the people. If anything, that effort only affirmed her belief i the staus quo and nothing more. In other words, she is more than likely to only continue leading kenya as simplyas it is and offers no fresh ideas or change for the better.

As regards her feminine side of things, we msut not ignore the fact that women politicians can be just as nasty as their male counter parts. Martha's personality does not indicate otherwise. The fact that she has not been stained by llegations of corruption yet does not necessarily mean that she will be a good leader given a chance. Being corruption free indeed should be a prerequisite of any of our public reps, although it appears in our case, that that is an exception rather than the rule.

Having said that, all this talk and efforts focused on Kibaki's succession is sadly a loss to the people of Kenya. As a nation which has just escaped by the skin of its teeth, from the possible total destruction after the recent G elections, a lot needs to be done that as a nation it may regain its fortunes and improve the lives of its people.

By the same note, Martha's responsibility as a minister for Justice leaves a lot to be desired. As our good Captain had observed above, the rot in our judicial system is nothing to be proud about. Murderers get acquited almost every week due to flimsy technicaities, thereby failing the desperate need for good application of justice for the good of the whole nation and especially the victims' family and all concerned. That aside, we are all too familiar with the daily scoop by police and their ilkes of innocent people, who are then arraigned in court, thrown a few tarmped up charges which they barely understand, and sent to prison or 'heavily' fined that they may be freed, all without any allowance for legal representaion that may ensure a degree of fair trial. That is sad.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
795
...
written by mkosakabila , August 08, 2008
No one is making such naive, if outright silly claims, women are human beings after all. But there might perhaps be some differences in the kind of reforms that women leaders pursue, and how they do it. I remember coming across some studies that seemed to suggest that women leaders at different levels of governance tended to implement reforms whose benefits are broadly distributed in society eg education, health, etc, and were less likely to pursue and implement reforms that concentrated benefits in a narrow segment of society eg privatizations.

Yes, its somewhat irritating that we're back into some kind of agitation, hardly before the dust settles, but just look at the GCG. Do you really expect anything useful to come out of it? I really hope they can muster sufficient cooperation to deliver a constitution.

"How in one house should many people, under two commands, hold amity? Tis hard; almost impossble!"

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
770
sexism.
written by Daniel.Waweru , August 08, 2008
For sure most of the people who hate Martha Karua so passionately have no reason other than her gender

Her performance as Justice Minister isn't immune to criticism, but she was extremely competent: the MoJC was easily the best-run Ministry in the first Kibaki administration; GJLOS has done very well; and her civil servants were competent and effective types. By common consent she is corruption-free - not even her worst enememis have claimed she misused GJLOS funds. The only complaint I've seen is that she used a government vehicle on a campaign trip.

If you've ever been at an ODM rally where her name has been mentioned, the criticism doesn't, how shall I put this, centre on her performance as Justice Minister (or even her very robust defence of PNU.) The key point of 'criticism' is that she's a woman who has gotten too big for her boots, and it is not expressed that benignly either. There's substantial truth to the sexism narrative I'm afraid.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
770
...
written by Daniel.Waweru , August 08, 2008
As regards her feminine side of things, we msut not ignore the fact that women politicians can be just as nasty as their male counter parts. Martha's personality does not indicate otherwise. The fact that she has not been stained by llegations of corruption yet does not necessarily mean that she will be a good leader given a chance. Being corruption free indeed should be a prerequisite of any of our public reps, although it appears in our case, that that is an exception rather than the rule.

Blatant double standard. We have politicians - such as the Bondo bumpkin - who've arranged for the murder and ethnic cleansing of thousands of their countrymen, and who've liberated billions of shillings from the public purse. Not even her enemies accuse Martha of those things, and yet she's being compared to them?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
929
...
written by Mlevi , August 08, 2008
Am I the only one that this conversation disturbing?

We are seven months from a really dark stage in our history based on election issues; and here we are arguing about the next elections!! we have yet to put the demons of the past elections to rest and now this?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
946
Karua too involved in the 2007 election fiasco
written by wuod aketch , August 08, 2008
Martha Karua, will find it hard to shed the image of one of those responsible for 2007 Kenya presidential election fiasco. John Michuki is in the same situation.
Nobody has forgotten neither that Martha lured a man of God into eating the forbidden fruit that she offered him.
Consequently, the best Martha can hope for is being a cabinet minister. Even this will be hard if the government is reshuffled.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
858
At Wuod Aketch
written by kanyonikanja , August 08, 2008
Were you there when Martha served the forbidden fruit to Wamugunda? If so, did she refuse to share some of that fruit with you?

NO?
Then shut up. This is pure conjecture and fabrication which cannot be supported with irrefutable factual evidence.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
270
...
written by Stephen Wanyama , August 08, 2008
The bigots did not take too long. It is not a matter of whether Martha Karua had a relationship with that collared man. We actually support her assuming she did, and taking that as none of our or your business. ODMers should be ashamed that they even think this is an argument to make against her leadership credentials.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
946
kanyonikanja
written by wuod aketch , August 08, 2008
I am very choosy in terms of beauty when it comes to matters of sharing fruit. I did not have to be there to have this info, were you? It was in the newspapers and still on the www: Kenya Minister in carjack terror — 7 December 2003 - Bonyeza hapa : Link Here
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
770
Yuck
written by Daniel.Waweru , August 08, 2008
Nobody has forgotten neither that Martha lured a man of God into eating the forbidden fruit that she offered him.

First, double standard. Male minister, past and present, have been found in significantly worse situations with no repercussions for their careers. (Remember the K-Street raid?) Second, precisely zero evidence that what you hope - or fear - happened, actually happened. Third, you really are a tiresome bigot.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
 1 2 3 > 
You can add your comment here

busy




Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!

Capt. Collins Wanderi Munyiri
About the author:
Captain (Rtd) Collins Wanderi is a Nairobi Advocate, Certified Public Secretary, Certified Fraud Examiner, Commissioner for Oaths, & Notary Public. He writes regularly on Kenyan affairs.
Last Updated ( Thursday, 07 August 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >


Archives | About Us | KenyaImagine How To | Privacy Policy | ContactUs | Join KenyaImagine |  Advertise Here| Legal Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Directory
rss-2.png

 

Copyright 2008 KenyaImagine.com, the KenyaImagine logo and KenyaImagine.com are trademarks of  the Six Degrees Media Company